Jonathan Todd

Recently Hector Sants, head of the Financial Services Authority (FSA), said:

“The question of the size of individual payments is not one for financial regulators. That is one for politicians and society as a whole. If politicians wish to take a view on that, then they should say so, but they should not be asking the regulator to carry out a pay policy”.

Politicians should step up to this plate. So, it is welcome to read reports that Alistair Darling, the Chancellor, is considering means of doing so.

Any nervousness that might be felt in relation to this should be quelled by reflection that Martin Wolf, Raghuram Rajan and Paul Krugman were arguing for this long ago. Of course, we should, as ever and as the Times argues, be wary about unintended consequences. But the Times – hardly a bastion of red blooded socialism! – proposes a sensible way ahead:

“Only a small fraction of a bonus should be paid at once. The rest of the payment would follow only if subsequent years of good performance confirmed that the profitability was sustainable. In this way, the incentive to make short-term profits with very risky transactions might be avoided. It would be reasonable to penalise banks that did not comply by requiring they offset the risk by holding more capital”.

Deferred compensation schemes seem the way forward.